In The Bell Jar, Sylvia Plath imagines life as a fig tree. On each branch, a fig represents a possibility: a career, a love, a way of being, a future among many others. The protagonist wants all the fruits, but she cannot choose. As she hesitates, the figs ripen, begin to rot, and fall. Paralyzed by the possibilities before her, she ends up with none.
The metaphor reveals something we are not always willing to admit: not choosing is also a choice. Hesitation does not suspend time, just as refusing to take a position does not prevent consequences from unfolding. While we wait for a certainty that may never come, some possibilities cease to exist.
This image also has something to say about the practice of law. Legal education teaches us to interpret rules, construct arguments, and anticipate consequences. We learn to identify risks and develop solutions that are technically defensible. But what should we do when the safest course is not necessarily the one that best aligns with the demands of the law?
The Courage to Challenge the Easiest Path
The practice of law requires constant choices. Among competing interpretations, available arguments, and conflicting interests, we must decide what to advocate and which consequences we are willing to accept.
The most difficult choice is not always the right one. Courage, by itself, does not make anyone right. There are, however, situations in which doing what seems right requires a willingness to defy expectations, face resistance, or question assumptions that have become so familiar they no longer seem to require justification.
This is particularly important in criminal law. Criminal practice unfolds amid tensions between the legitimate expectation of accountability and the limits imposed on the state’s punitive power. These dimensions are not incompatible. It is precisely the observance of legal limits that distinguishes the legitimate exercise of power from its arbitrary use.
The problem begins when procedural safeguards are perceived as inconveniences, when due process seems secondary to the desired outcome, or when the complexity of a case is reduced to the need for an immediate response. Under such circumstances, defending the limits of power can become an uncomfortable position to take.
This is where legal expertise reveals its limits. Knowing the law does not, in itself, resolve the question of whether we are willing to uphold its requirements when they conflict with our expectations. Legal courage does not consist of challenging everything, but of refusing to replace the examination of reasons with the convenience of a conclusion.
The Legacy of the Legal Profession
The history of the Brazilian legal profession also includes lawyers who, during the military dictatorship, defended persecuted individuals and sought to preserve spaces for dissent in a climate of restricted freedoms. Even when they could not guarantee outcomes, these lawyers kept open the possibility of challenging accusations and demanding justification for the exercise of power.
This legacy does not need to be idealized to remain meaningful. It reminds us that the practice of law involves choices that extend beyond technical expertise, and that the meaning of professional conduct is also revealed in the positions we choose to uphold.
Thinking Before Judging
This is where Hannah Arendt’s reflections become relevant. In examining the relationship between thought, responsibility, and judgment, Arendt drew attention to the dangers of acting without considering the meaning and consequences of one’s own actions.
Thinking does not simply mean accumulating information or mastering concepts. It means interrupting the automatic course of events to examine what presents itself as self-evident, confront our own justifications, and ask whether they withstand reflection.
The law depends on this capacity. Judges must examine the reasons for which they convict or acquit. Prosecutors must test their hypotheses against the evidence and legal limits. Lawyers must question not only opposing arguments but also the assumptions underlying their own conduct. In each of these roles, responsibility extends beyond the formal fulfillment of a professional function.
Perhaps this is why thinking can, in certain circumstances, be a form of courage. Not because it always leads to extraordinary answers, but because it prevents familiarity with a practice from being mistaken for its justification.
The Figs We Choose to Leave Behind
Let us return to Sylvia Plath’s fig tree.
Every choice entails renunciation. We cannot live every possible life, follow every path, or simultaneously uphold every position. Maturity may consist less in eliminating this loss than in recognizing it as an inevitable part of any decision.
In the practice of law, choices extend beyond personal fulfillment. They concern how we understand our responsibility and which limits we are willing to respect, even when ignoring them would be more convenient.
There is no guarantee that the right decision will be rewarded. Nor does courage free us from the possibility of being wrong. Rather, it requires that we not turn uncertainty into a justification for permanent inaction. We must choose, but we must also continue thinking after making our choice: revisiting arguments, acknowledging mistakes, and accepting that our reasons be subjected to the same scrutiny we apply to the reasons of others.
Perhaps it is impossible to pick every fig. We can, however, decide which ones are worth reaching for and why. Some choices will come at a cost, and we will not always find approval as we follow the paths we have chosen.
What we cannot do is imagine that the absence of choice keeps us safe from its consequences.
Ultimately, the question is not merely what kind of future we wish to build, but what responsibility we are willing to assume to make it possible. In law, that responsibility begins when we understand that thinking, choosing, and upholding the limits of power are not secondary tasks in the practice of the profession. They are part of what gives it meaning.




