In fraud cases, venue depends on how the scheme was carried out and where the offense was completed. Law No. 14,155/2021 created a special rule for certain situations, but it did not make the victim’s place of residence the deciding factor in every case.
A fraud victim may live in one city, make a financial transaction in another, and discover the scam in a third. Which court, then, should oversee the investigation and try the case?
The answer depends on how the fraud was committed. Although Law No. 14,155/2021 placed venue in the victim’s place of residence in certain situations, the rule does not cover every form of fraud under Article 171 of the Brazilian Criminal Code.
The distinction matters because the place where the victim files a police report or learns of the fraud does not, on its own, determine venue. The type of fraud must be identified and the corresponding rule of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CPP) applied.
The General Rule: Venue Lies Where the Offense Is Completed
As a general rule, Article 70 of the CPP places venue where the offense is completed or, in the case of an attempt, where the last act of execution took place.
In fraud cases, pinpointing that location requires a close look at the elements of Article 171 of the Criminal Code, which defines the offense as obtaining an unlawful gain, to another’s detriment, by inducing or keeping the victim in error. The deception, the financial loss, and the gain may each occur in a different place, and venue turns on how those elements played out in the conduct under investigation.
Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice (STJ) addressed this issue in Conflict of Jurisdiction (CC) No. 167,025/RS[1], decided by its Third Section on August 14, 2019. The case involved a fraud in which the victim voluntarily made a deposit and a bank transfer, and the Court held that the crime was completed when the funds came under the offender’s control, that is, in the bank account that received them.
The Court distinguished that scenario from fraud committed with an altered or forged check, in which the gain is tied to the withdrawal of funds from the victim’s account, and made clear that the place where the offense is completed depends on how the crime was carried out.
What Changed with Law No. 14,155/2021?
Law No. 14,155/2021 added paragraph 4 to Article 70 of the CPP, establishing a special venue rule for fraud committed by means of:
- a deposit;
- a check drawn on insufficient funds held by the drawee bank, or on which payment is stopped;
- a transfer of funds.
In these cases, venue lies in the victim’s place of residence. When there are multiple victims, venue goes to the court that first took cognizance of the case.
The amendment mainly reversed the approach previously applied to deposits and bank transfers. Before the new law, the STJ placed venue in those cases where the funds entered the offender’s account; under the new rule, the victim’s place of residence controls. Paragraph 4, however, lists specific methods of commission and does not allow that rule to be extended to every fraud.
When the scheme does not fit any of them, the general rule of Article 70 of the CPP still applies, as the STJ itself has recognized.
The STJ and the Limits of Venue Based on the Victim’s Residence
In CC No. 185,983/DF[2], decided on May 11, 2022, the STJ’s Third Section examined a fraud involving travel services obtained through sham contracts. The company that suffered the loss was headquartered somewhere other than where the suspects allegedly obtained the benefits, and the question was whether venue should follow the victim company’s domicile or the place where the gain was obtained.
The Court held that paragraph 4 of Article 70 did not apply, since there had been no deposit, transfer of funds, or check under the conditions set out in the statute, and, applying the general venue rule, it found venue proper where the offenders allegedly obtained the services paid for by the victim.
The decision confirms that Law No. 14,155/2021 did not wholly replace the place-of-completion test with the victim’s residence. It also shows that the unlawful gain need not be money and that, where the fraud involves obtaining goods or services, the place where they were obtained may determine venue.
The STJ had already taken this approach in CC No. 113,947/PA[3], decided on February 26, 2014, when it looked to the place where goods obtained through fraud were received. Although it predates Law No. 14,155/2021, the decision remains useful for understanding when fraud is completed in the forms not covered by the special rule.
The Third Section returned to the subject in 2023, ruling on an internal appeal (agravo regimental) in CC No. 192,274/RJ[4], and reaffirmed that paragraph 4 “does not, and could not, cover every situation involving the crime of fraud.” Although the scheme involved transfers of funds, the victim was an investment fund headquartered abroad, and the transactions had taken place outside Brazil.
The Court placed venue in the city where the acts allegedly took place, where the defendants’ company was based, citing, among other reasons, the gathering of evidence and the exercise of the right of defense. It also refused to shift venue to the city where one of the fund’s partners reportedly lived, because the victim was the legal entity that had dealt with the defendants, not each partner individually.
When the Fraud Merely Resembles the Situations in Paragraph 4
Nor does the victim’s-residence rule apply when the fraud merely comes close to the methods described in paragraph 4. In CC No. 182,977/PR[5], decided on March 9, 2022, the STJ examined an attempt to clear a forged check drawn on the victim’s account and ruled out the special rule. Although both forms of conduct involve a check, using a counterfeit check is not the same as writing a check without sufficient funds or stopping payment on it. Applying the general rule, the Third Section placed venue where the victim’s bank branch was located, the place where the withdrawal would have been authorized.
This outcome is consistent with the distinction drawn in CC No. 167,025/RS. In this scenario, the money leaves the victim’s account directly, so the drawee branch is where both the loss and the gain occur.
Not every fraud involving a deposit, a transfer, or a check, therefore, falls under the 2021 special rule, and the type of fraud must be examined before determining the proper court. The decision also shows why the victim’s-residence rule cannot simply be replaced by another equally sweeping assertion, namely that every fraud must be tried where the offender receives the gain.
The test remains the place where the offense was completed, determined in light of the conduct under investigation.
How Do You Identify the Proper Court in a Fraud Investigation?
The first step is to determine whether the conduct actually amounts to fraud. Paragraph 4 of Article 70 refers only to offenses under Article 171 of the Criminal Code, and some banking scams may, in principle, constitute theft by fraud (furto mediante fraude), in which the offender takes the funds out of the victim’s control without the victim handing them over.
The STJ addressed this distinction in CC No. 113,947/PA, holding that the victim’s own participation is essential to characterize fraud and noting that, in theft aggravated by fraud, the offense is completed when the victim’s assets are depleted. In that situation, the special victim’s-residence rule does not apply, and venue follows the general place-of-completion rule.
If the conduct does amount to fraud, determining venue involves two successive questions. The first is whether the method under investigation matches one of the situations listed in paragraph 4 of Article 70; if it does, the special victim’s-residence rule applies. If it does not, the place where the offense was completed must be identified under the general rule of Article 70, subject to the other statutory venue rules.
This analysis must start from the facts under investigation, without assuming the accusation is true. Identifying the proper court does not mean acknowledging that a fraud occurred or that the suspects are responsible. Nor is it enough to consider where the victim filed the police report, since filing a criminal complaint does not change the statutory venue rules. When the place of the offense is unknown, Article 72 of the CPP provides, as a fallback, the defendant’s domicile or residence.
Properly identifying the competent court therefore depends on applying procedural rules to the conduct described, not on choosing the most convenient location for whoever reports the alleged offense.
Conclusion
Law No. 14,155/2021 changed the venue rules only for certain forms of fraud. Outside the situations listed in paragraph 4 of Article 70 of the CPP, the STJ continues to apply the general place-of-completion rule, determined by how the fraud was carried out and the nature of the gain obtained. The victim’s place of residence, therefore, is not a universal venue rule in fraud cases.
[1] STJ, Third Section, CC No. 167,025/RS, Rapporteur Justice Reynaldo Soares da Fonseca, decided Aug. 14, 2019, published Aug. 28, 2019.
[2] STJ, Third Section, CC No. 185,983/DF, Rapporteur Justice Joel Ilan Paciornik, decided May 11, 2022, published May 13, 2022.
[3] STJ, Third Section, CC No. 113,947/PA, Rapporteur Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze, decided Feb. 26, 2014, published Mar. 6, 2014.
[4] STJ, Third Section, AgRg in CC No. 192,274/RJ, Rapporteur Justice Ribeiro Dantas, decided Mar. 8, 2023, published Mar. 10, 2023.
[5] STJ, Third Section, CC No. 182,977/PR, Rapporteur Justice Laurita Vaz, decided Mar. 9, 2022, published Mar. 14, 2022.




